Redefining Transparency in the Ad Industry

Written by:

Jacek Chrusciany

Published

Jan 17, 2024

Read time

3 min

Our CEO and Co-Founder Jacek Chrusciany wrote an article “Redefining Transparency in the Ad Industry” featured in AdvertisingWeek.com.

Link to the original article: Adfidence CEO on Transparency in AdvertisingWeek


A reprint of this article can be found below.


By Jacek Chrusciany, CEO and Co-Founder of Adfidence

The term “transparency” gets tossed around a lot in our industry. Perhaps it is no surprise when ANA ranks it as #3 in its annual “word of the year” study – as it did last month.

However, as MediaPost’s Joe Mandese also recently noted, how the ad industry interprets transparency is not quite as straightforward as it is in other industries, especially regulated ones.

Instead, the ad industry standard is to limit visibility to certain specific stakeholders, such as advertisers and agencies – mainly for competitive advantage within that group.

And who pays the price for this arrangement? Brands, mainly. They are the ones who continue to tolerate this “fraction of every programmatic dollar” reaching its intended destination. They accept the final metrics as the indicators of success, without ever knowing the true impact of their work.

What if we as an industry committed instead to delivering comprehensive brand insights with every ad placement – before those campaigns even begin? Not just understanding where ads appear, but how they appear and how they will align with brand values and impact the audience. (And not just when they create a brand crisis, like Bud Light or Pepsi – most recently.)

To accomplish this, we need strong company-level stewardship and a transparency akin to Wall Street’s – but beyond. One that zooms out even further than simple financials. It’s the only way we can address the issues of inefficiencies, mark-ups, and bad inventory that plague our current system.

And this isn’t about adding another reporting function for entry-level media buyers to own and monitor. To shift this paradigm, the awareness needs to shift at the industry leader level – the global heads of media, and even CMOs. From here, we must build a digital advertising environment rooted in ethical practices and genuine transparency.

For many that seems scary, to shake up the status quo like this. What will happen to all of those non-executive media buying roles if “Big Brother” is looking over their shoulders with this level of scrutiny?

The position levels up – that’s what happens.

Rather than being judged, for example, by the millions of unvalidated views and clicks after a campaign wraps, these junior roles can be measured by the quality of the value they bring to aligning a campaign to a brand’s stated mission and purpose. How much more interesting and satisfying of a role would that be?

Because this also isn’t just about ensuring financial efficiency; it’s about considering the broader impact of our practices. As digital advertising evolves, so must our commitment to contributing positively to the world we live in.

So the question is no longer if we need comprehensive transparency but how we can achieve it. It starts with this very conversation: questioning and challenging the status quo.

We also need to shift the focus from a forensic analysis of the final outcome to the governance of the campaign from the outset. It is the only way to evolve from reactive monitoring to proactive, informed decision-making. If a buyer cannot look ahead to his or her campaign with confidence in its transparency, how can they design this campaign strategically?

Digital advertising is complex, for sure. But that doesn’t mean we need to completely give up on control and understanding. The tools to create a more transparent, ethical, and trustworthy industry are here – and they are actionable and easy to use. So let’s create a new vision for our work, where it can be not just effective, but also conscientious and responsible.

Redefining Transparency in the Ad Industry

Written by:

Jacek Chrusciany

Published

Jan 17, 2024

Read time

3 min

Our CEO and Co-Founder Jacek Chrusciany wrote an article “Redefining Transparency in the Ad Industry” featured in AdvertisingWeek.com.

Link to the original article: Adfidence CEO on Transparency in AdvertisingWeek


A reprint of this article can be found below.


By Jacek Chrusciany, CEO and Co-Founder of Adfidence

The term “transparency” gets tossed around a lot in our industry. Perhaps it is no surprise when ANA ranks it as #3 in its annual “word of the year” study – as it did last month.

However, as MediaPost’s Joe Mandese also recently noted, how the ad industry interprets transparency is not quite as straightforward as it is in other industries, especially regulated ones.

Instead, the ad industry standard is to limit visibility to certain specific stakeholders, such as advertisers and agencies – mainly for competitive advantage within that group.

And who pays the price for this arrangement? Brands, mainly. They are the ones who continue to tolerate this “fraction of every programmatic dollar” reaching its intended destination. They accept the final metrics as the indicators of success, without ever knowing the true impact of their work.

What if we as an industry committed instead to delivering comprehensive brand insights with every ad placement – before those campaigns even begin? Not just understanding where ads appear, but how they appear and how they will align with brand values and impact the audience. (And not just when they create a brand crisis, like Bud Light or Pepsi – most recently.)

To accomplish this, we need strong company-level stewardship and a transparency akin to Wall Street’s – but beyond. One that zooms out even further than simple financials. It’s the only way we can address the issues of inefficiencies, mark-ups, and bad inventory that plague our current system.

And this isn’t about adding another reporting function for entry-level media buyers to own and monitor. To shift this paradigm, the awareness needs to shift at the industry leader level – the global heads of media, and even CMOs. From here, we must build a digital advertising environment rooted in ethical practices and genuine transparency.

For many that seems scary, to shake up the status quo like this. What will happen to all of those non-executive media buying roles if “Big Brother” is looking over their shoulders with this level of scrutiny?

The position levels up – that’s what happens.

Rather than being judged, for example, by the millions of unvalidated views and clicks after a campaign wraps, these junior roles can be measured by the quality of the value they bring to aligning a campaign to a brand’s stated mission and purpose. How much more interesting and satisfying of a role would that be?

Because this also isn’t just about ensuring financial efficiency; it’s about considering the broader impact of our practices. As digital advertising evolves, so must our commitment to contributing positively to the world we live in.

So the question is no longer if we need comprehensive transparency but how we can achieve it. It starts with this very conversation: questioning and challenging the status quo.

We also need to shift the focus from a forensic analysis of the final outcome to the governance of the campaign from the outset. It is the only way to evolve from reactive monitoring to proactive, informed decision-making. If a buyer cannot look ahead to his or her campaign with confidence in its transparency, how can they design this campaign strategically?

Digital advertising is complex, for sure. But that doesn’t mean we need to completely give up on control and understanding. The tools to create a more transparent, ethical, and trustworthy industry are here – and they are actionable and easy to use. So let’s create a new vision for our work, where it can be not just effective, but also conscientious and responsible.

Redefining Transparency in the Ad Industry

Written by:

Jacek Chrusciany

Published

Jan 17, 2024

Read time

3 min

Our CEO and Co-Founder Jacek Chrusciany wrote an article “Redefining Transparency in the Ad Industry” featured in AdvertisingWeek.com.

Link to the original article: Adfidence CEO on Transparency in AdvertisingWeek


A reprint of this article can be found below.


By Jacek Chrusciany, CEO and Co-Founder of Adfidence

The term “transparency” gets tossed around a lot in our industry. Perhaps it is no surprise when ANA ranks it as #3 in its annual “word of the year” study – as it did last month.

However, as MediaPost’s Joe Mandese also recently noted, how the ad industry interprets transparency is not quite as straightforward as it is in other industries, especially regulated ones.

Instead, the ad industry standard is to limit visibility to certain specific stakeholders, such as advertisers and agencies – mainly for competitive advantage within that group.

And who pays the price for this arrangement? Brands, mainly. They are the ones who continue to tolerate this “fraction of every programmatic dollar” reaching its intended destination. They accept the final metrics as the indicators of success, without ever knowing the true impact of their work.

What if we as an industry committed instead to delivering comprehensive brand insights with every ad placement – before those campaigns even begin? Not just understanding where ads appear, but how they appear and how they will align with brand values and impact the audience. (And not just when they create a brand crisis, like Bud Light or Pepsi – most recently.)

To accomplish this, we need strong company-level stewardship and a transparency akin to Wall Street’s – but beyond. One that zooms out even further than simple financials. It’s the only way we can address the issues of inefficiencies, mark-ups, and bad inventory that plague our current system.

And this isn’t about adding another reporting function for entry-level media buyers to own and monitor. To shift this paradigm, the awareness needs to shift at the industry leader level – the global heads of media, and even CMOs. From here, we must build a digital advertising environment rooted in ethical practices and genuine transparency.

For many that seems scary, to shake up the status quo like this. What will happen to all of those non-executive media buying roles if “Big Brother” is looking over their shoulders with this level of scrutiny?

The position levels up – that’s what happens.

Rather than being judged, for example, by the millions of unvalidated views and clicks after a campaign wraps, these junior roles can be measured by the quality of the value they bring to aligning a campaign to a brand’s stated mission and purpose. How much more interesting and satisfying of a role would that be?

Because this also isn’t just about ensuring financial efficiency; it’s about considering the broader impact of our practices. As digital advertising evolves, so must our commitment to contributing positively to the world we live in.

So the question is no longer if we need comprehensive transparency but how we can achieve it. It starts with this very conversation: questioning and challenging the status quo.

We also need to shift the focus from a forensic analysis of the final outcome to the governance of the campaign from the outset. It is the only way to evolve from reactive monitoring to proactive, informed decision-making. If a buyer cannot look ahead to his or her campaign with confidence in its transparency, how can they design this campaign strategically?

Digital advertising is complex, for sure. But that doesn’t mean we need to completely give up on control and understanding. The tools to create a more transparent, ethical, and trustworthy industry are here – and they are actionable and easy to use. So let’s create a new vision for our work, where it can be not just effective, but also conscientious and responsible.

Read more

Read more

Sep 20, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: The Persistent Illusion of Brand Safety in Digital Advertising

Jacek Chrusciany
Sep 6, 2024

Ad Age: How Brands Are Battling Digital Media Buying Confusion with a New Tool

Jack Neff
Aug 20, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: Why Aren't Brands Using the Tools They’ve Said They Need?

Jacek Chrusciany
Jul 5, 2024

Adfidence CEO Shares Insights at Cannes Panel

Brand Innovators
May 30, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: The Growing Complexity of Today’s Media Buying

Jacek Chrusciany
May 17, 2024

Adfidence is a Proud Sponsor of WFA Global Marketer Week

Adfidence Team
May 5, 2024

Setting Agency Guardrails: 4 Tips for Success

Jacek Chrusciany
Apr 24, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: Limitations of YouTube Target Frequency

Jacek Chrusciany
Apr 24, 2024

Campaign Setup Day Series Launched in London

Adfidence Team
Mar 26, 2024

The Shocking Divide Between Media Strategy and Execution

Jacek Chrusciany
Mar 26, 2024

Is User-Rewarded Content the New MFA?

Jacek Chrusciany
Mar 25, 2024

The Hidden Risks of User Rewarded Content

Adfidence Team
Mar 13, 2024

How to Weed Out Made-For-Advertising (MFA) Inventory?

Jacek Chruściany
Feb 12, 2024

YouTube and Meta Don’t Care About Your Brand’s Safety

Jacek Chrusciany
Nov 29, 2023

Opt Out of Controversial Google Search Partners

Adfidence Team
Sep 25, 2023

Interview with Adfidence CEO

Tom Triscari, Jacek Chrusciany
Sep 11, 2023

How Can Advertisers Navigate the YouTube Made-For-Kids Controversy?

Adfidence Team
Aug 17, 2023

A Checkbox That Can Save $ Millions

Adfidence Team
Apr 6, 2023

Join Adfidence in Cannes!

Jacek Chruściany
Mar 15, 2023

Savings From Often-forgotten Language Settings

Adfidence Team