How Can Advertisers Navigate the YouTube Made-For-Kids Controversy?

How Can Advertisers Navigate the YouTube Made-For-Kids Controversy?

Written by:

Adfidence Team

Published

Sep 11, 2023

Read time

3 min

Evidence collected by research company Adalytics suggests that YouTube ads targeted for adults might inadvertently be appearing on children's channels. Furthermore, they could be collecting children’s personal data. While advertisers might feel they lack full control to prevent this, proper settings can significantly reduce the risk. To shield your brand and conserve your budget, some of the top advertisers decide to exclude "Content Suitable for Families”, which is the closest proxy for kids-content available in campaign setup. The Adfidence platform offers an automated rule to facilitate such exclusions on a global scale.

Unpacking Adalytics' Claims

Back in 2019, Google settled a case with the FTC over collecting children's personal data without parental consent. Following this, YouTube’s CEO committed to halting the display of personalized ads on content tailored for kids and vowed to stop data collection on such content.

Yet, come July 2023, Adalytics alleges that YouTube is displaying personalized ads on made-for-kids (MFK) channels and might also be harvesting data from young viewers.

Ads from large advertisers, inc. Mars, Samsung, and Ford, targeted at adult audiences have been spotted on children’s channels. This suggests that advertisers could inadvertently be collecting data from underage viewers, raising privacy concerns.

Google's Perspective

In response to Adalytics' claims, Google portrayed the findings as potentially misreading YouTube's advertising protocols for children's content. They assert their strict policy against ad personalization or child-targeting across all their products. Google has also reached out to Adalytics for further insights and highlighted the feature allowing advertisers to opt-out of displaying their ads alongside "made-for-kids" content on YouTube.

Safeguarding Your Brand's Reputation and Budgets

As the digital marketing industry casts a critical eye on Google’s practices, brands are left questioning: How can we protect our ads on YouTube?

There might not be a one-size-fits-all answer, and fully addressing every concern is challenging. Still, certain measures can shield brands from undue exposure. A proactive step is to exclude specific content types, with many brands already opting to exclude "Content Suitable for Families", which is the closest proxy for kids-content that is available in settings. 

However, this process grows intricate for global advertisers overseeing multiple ad accounts. This is where Adfidence steps up, introducing an automated check within our platform. Brands receive alerts for any YouTube ad that does not adhere to the “Content Suitable for Families” exclusion, allowing for easy identification and prompt adjustments.

For further information, please connect with our dedicated team at contact@adfidence.com.

Read more

Read more

Sep 20, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: The Persistent Illusion of Brand Safety in Digital Advertising

Jacek Chrusciany
Sep 6, 2024

Ad Age: How Brands Are Battling Digital Media Buying Confusion with a New Tool

Jack Neff
Aug 20, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: Why Aren't Brands Using the Tools They’ve Said They Need?

Jacek Chrusciany
May 30, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: The Growing Complexity of Today’s Media Buying

Jacek Chrusciany
May 17, 2024

Adfidence is a Proud Sponsor of WFA Global Marketer Week

Adfidence Team
May 8, 2024

Let the Buyers Beware: In Digital Advertising, Nothing Is as It Seems

Jacek Chrusciany
May 5, 2024

Setting Agency Guardrails: 4 Tips for Success

Jacek Chrusciany
Apr 24, 2024

Pathways to Transparent Media: Limitations of YouTube Target Frequency

Jacek Chrusciany
Apr 24, 2024

Campaign Setup Day Series Launched in London

Adfidence Team
Mar 26, 2024

The Shocking Divide Between Media Strategy and Execution

Jacek Chrusciany
Mar 26, 2024

Is User-Rewarded Content the New MFA?

Jacek Chrusciany
Mar 25, 2024

The Hidden Risks of User Rewarded Content

Adfidence Team
Mar 13, 2024

How to Weed Out Made-For-Advertising (MFA) Inventory?

Jacek Chruściany
Feb 12, 2024

YouTube and Meta Don’t Care About Your Brand’s Safety

Jacek Chrusciany
Jan 17, 2024

Redefining Transparency in the Ad Industry

Jacek Chrusciany
Nov 29, 2023

Opt Out of Controversial Google Search Partners

Adfidence Team
Sep 25, 2023

Interview with Adfidence CEO

Tom Triscari, Jacek Chrusciany
Aug 17, 2023

A Checkbox That Can Save $ Millions

Adfidence Team
Jul 5, 2023

Adfidence CEO Shares Insights at Cannes Panel

Brand Innovators
Apr 6, 2023

Join Adfidence in Cannes!

Jacek Chruściany
Mar 15, 2023

Savings From Often-forgotten Language Settings

Adfidence Team